The feud escalated from a disputed trainer-client relationship into a national political and legal spectacle. After Clemens filed a defamation lawsuit against McNamee, the two men spoke by telephone on January 4, 2008, with Clemens repeatedly insisting that the steroid accusations were false while McNamee refused to retract them, saying, "It is what it is." On February 13, 2008, both appeared before the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform and accused the other of lying. The controversy widened when McNamee said Clemens's wife, Debra, had used human growth hormone in preparation for a 2003 Sports Illustrated swimsuit appearance; she acknowledged using HGH but said Clemens did not know. Andy Pettitte separately admitted using HGH supplied by McNamee in 2002 and obtaining it from his father in 2004. McNamee later became the prosecution's central witness at Clemens's 2012 federal perjury trial, but conceded that his account had "evolved" over time. His inconsistencies became a central weakness in the government's case, and Clemens was acquitted of all charges. A federal judge had already dismissed claims based on McNamee's statements to investigators, ruling that his cooperation with federal officials protected those statements, while allowing claims involving statements made to Pettitte to proceed. The verdict did not erase the steroid allegations from baseball history, but it ensured that Clemens's legal record ended in acquittal rather than conviction.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.