Walter East, Sherburn Wightman, Ed Stewart, Tiny Maxwell, and Bob Shiring / 1900s
The most specific fixing allegation involved Walter East, a baseball player who had played end for Massillon. According to manager Ed Stewart, East approached Tigers players Tiny Maxwell and Bob Shiring before the first 1906 game and solicited them to throw it, claiming that he was backed by $50,000. Maxwell and Shiring reported the approach to coach Sherburn Wightman, and East was released. East then offered a radically different version: he claimed Wightman had instructed him to recruit the players and locate a backer willing to pay Wightman $4,000. East produced a contract bearing the signatures of himself, Wightman, and John T. Windsor, an owner of East’s Akron baseball team. Windsor acknowledged his involvement and said he had never even met Wallace. Wightman admitted signing the document but said he had done so as part of a counter-scheme authorized by Stewart and Massillon’s backers—to play along, identify anyone willing to participate in a fix, and obtain documentary evidence. Stewart supported Wightman’s explanation, while East insisted that the coach had engineered the entire affair and later claimed that no Canton player or backer, to his knowledge, was involved. The competing testimony made the bribery episode impossible to resolve definitively, but it helped permanently stain the reputations of both clubs and contributed to the decline of professional football in Ohio until the middle of the 1910s.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.