The February 11, 2011 rematch at Nassau Coliseum became one of the most chaotic regular-season games in NHL history. New York, fueled by anger over Blake Comeau's concussion and the earlier knockout of goaltender Rick DiPietro, won 9–3 while the teams accumulated a record-setting 65 penalties and 346 penalty minutes, including 15 fighting majors and 21 game misconducts. The Islanders raced to a 6–0 lead, then Matt Martin targeted Maxime Talbot in a retaliatory confrontation that instantly split into three simultaneous fights: Martin with Deryk Engelland, Josh Bailey with Pascal Dupuis, and Travis Hamonic with Mike Rupp. All six players were ejected. The violence escalated in the third period when Trevor Gillies elbowed Pittsburgh's Eric Tangradi in the head, leaving Tangradi apparently concussed and later sidelined for nearly six weeks. Gillies continued taunting the injured player from the runway even after his ejection. Another fight erupted between Micheal Haley and Talbot, and Penguins enforcer Eric Godard illegally left the bench to defend his goaltender, earning an automatic 10-game suspension. Gillies was suspended nine games, Martin four, and the Islanders organization was fined $100,000 for failing to control its players. Penguins owner Mario Lemieux condemned the league for allowing conduct he called unacceptable and embarrassing, while Brian Burke and Milan Lucic argued that the NHL had acted swiftly and appropriately. The game left Pittsburgh with only seven eligible players and New York with nine by the final horn, becoming a lasting example of the NHL's old fighting culture colliding with growing concern over concussions and deliberate injury.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.