Decades after the fight, former Dempsey manager Jack Kearns made a sensational claim in the January 20, 1964 issue of Sports Illustrated. Kearns said he had wagered his share of the purse on Dempsey winning by first-round knockout and had supposedly applied plaster of Paris to Dempsey's hand wrappings. Dempsey sued Time Inc. for $3 million, and the dispute was settled out of court. The allegation was already suspect because it conflicted with other witnesses' accounts of the wrapping procedure, while a later Boxing Illustrated demonstration argued that plaster would crack on the first impact and could seriously injure the puncher as well as the opponent.
Jess Willard added an even stranger version of the story when interviewed by Harry Carpenter in the 1960s. Willard produced a metal bolt and claimed Dempsey had concealed a similar object in the palm of his glove, using it to slice his face and cause the fight's bloodshed. Mike Tyson, who discussed the case with Carpenter and admired Dempsey, acknowledged that boxing in that era had weak oversight and that almost anything might have happened. However, surviving pre-fight footage shows Dempsey putting on his gloves in full view of Willard, his corner, and the crowd. During the bout he also appears to use the alleged glove hand to hold, push, and grasp the ropes, actions that make a concealed bolt highly implausible. The plaster and hidden-weapon stories remain colorful pieces of boxing folklore, but the available evidence does not substantiate them.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.