Joel Casamayor vs. José Santa Cruz / 2000s
On November 10, 2007, Joel Casamayor defended his lightweight championship against José Santa Cruz at Madison Square Garden, but the bout became overshadowed by one of boxing's most disputed judging controversies of the year. Santa Cruz appeared to control much of the fight after scoring a flash knockdown with a counter straight left to the body in the opening minute. Compubox statistics supported his performance: Santa Cruz reportedly landed 246 of 801 punches, while Casamayor connected with only 129 of 502. Santa Cruz also outworked the champion and seemed to be winning the majority of the rounds to observers at ringside. Yet when the scorecards were read, Tony Paolillo had Santa Cruz ahead 114–113, while Ron McNair and Frank Lombardi scored the fight 114–113 for Casamayor, giving the champion a split-decision victory. The result was met by loud boos from the crowd and immediate condemnation from HBO's broadcast team. Unofficial HBO scorer Harold Lederman scored the fight 118–109 for Santa Cruz, while ESPN had it 119–108 for the challenger. Jim Lampley said, 'Just when you think you've seen everything' in judging, a decision like this appeared; veteran trainer and commentator Emanuel Steward called it a 'bad, disgusting decision.' There was no established finding in the supplied account that the judges had been bribed or that the bout was fixed, but the extreme gap between the official result, the punch statistics, and the independent ringside scores made the episode a lasting example of boxing's credibility problem: a champion retained his title despite widespread belief that he had been outboxed.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.