The Islanders–Rangers rivalry became a genuine playoff feud almost as soon as the Islanders entered the NHL. The league created the Islanders in 1971 largely to block the World Hockey Association from placing the New York Raiders at Nassau Coliseum, but imposed a $4 million territorial fee payable to the established Rangers. That financial arrangement immediately gave the expansion club an antagonistic relationship with its Manhattan neighbor. In the 1975 playoffs, the Islanders upset the heavily favored Rangers in a best-of-three series when J. P. Parise scored 11 seconds into overtime of the deciding game at Madison Square Garden. The Rangers answered in 1979, eliminating an Islanders team that had finished first overall and advancing to the Stanley Cup Final, reinforcing the Islanders’ reputation for playoff collapses.
The rivalry reached its most intense competitive phase from 1981 through 1984. The Islanders eliminated the Rangers in four consecutive playoff series, including a 4–0 sweep in 1981, while winning three straight Stanley Cups during that span and appearing in four consecutive Finals. Rangers supporters responded with the enduring “1940” chant, mocking the club’s long Stanley Cup drought that dated to its 1940 championship. In 1994, the Rangers finally reversed the psychological balance by sweeping the Islanders 4–0 in the opening round and then winning their first Stanley Cup since 1940. The rivalry’s lasting folklore is therefore built not only on games, but on years of humiliation, championship droughts, and one fan base repeatedly weaponizing the other team’s historical failures.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.