Rick Butler, USA Volleyball, AAU, and Junior Volleyball Association / 1990s-2020s
The controversy resurfaced repeatedly as Butler's club became one of the most successful youth volleyball organizations in the United States, eventually claiming 100 national championships. USA Volleyball initially banned him from coaching girls in August 1995, partially lifted that ban in 2000, and reinstated his membership, while the program continued to operate outside USA Volleyball events after 2007. Following renewed media scrutiny, including an Outside the Lines report in 2015, Butler stepped down as an Illinois Amateur Athletic Union district director. USA Volleyball imposed a lifetime ban in December 2017 for violating a rule concerning disclosure of information about its complaint, then conducted a second hearing in January 2018—without Butler, who called it a sham—and issued another lifetime ban tied to its finding that his conduct violated the organization's 1995 standards and brought it into public embarrassment or ridicule. The AAU permanently disqualified him in February 2018 after previously honoring him with a leadership award and allowing him to participate in under-18 events; the Junior Volleyball Association followed with an indefinite suspension. In 2018, a parent-led class action alleging that the Butlers concealed the old allegations from families was dismissed on summary judgment. In December 2021, Butler, his wife Cheryl, and their company filed a $250 million lawsuit alleging that Nancy Hogshead-Makar, Champion Women, and others had orchestrated a campaign of negative publicity, legal pressure, and cancellation to destroy the business. The saga became a landmark example of the conflict between due-process arguments, institutional reputation, and child-protection policies in youth sports.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.