Charles Martin, Jim McMahon, Green Bay Packers vs. Chicago Bears / 1980s
On November 23, 1986, during a game between the 10–2 Chicago Bears and the 2–10 Green Bay Packers, Packers defensive end Charles Martin wore a white towel displaying the jersey numbers of five Bears offensive players: quarterback Jim McMahon, Walter Payton, Willie Gault, Jay Hilgenberg, and Dennis Gentry. The towel was widely interpreted as a hit list, reinforcing Martin’s already notorious reputation and nickname, “Too Mean.” After McMahon threw an interception, Martin ignored the developing play and grabbed the quarterback from behind, driving him shoulder-first into Soldier Field’s artificial turf. McMahon was already playing through a torn rotator cuff, and the impact caused further damage that required surgery and ended his 1986 season. Bears lineman Jim Covert retaliated with a late hit, initially producing offsetting penalties, but referee Jerry Markbreit decided Martin’s act was so egregious that only the Packers were penalized. Markbreit ejected Martin, telling him he was “out of the game”; Martin initially resisted but ultimately left the field. The league suspended him for two games, the first modern NFL multi-game suspension for an on-field incident. The episode also established a precedent that a violent act outside the normal action of football could warrant ejection. The controversy deepened when Green Bay defensive coordinator expressed the philosophy that players should hit anyone near an interception, while the Bears viewed Martin’s tackle as a deliberate assault on an injured quarterback. The incident remains one of the defining examples of the NFL’s transformation toward stricter punishment for retaliatory and gratuitous violence.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.