British Boxing Board of Control investigation into Josh Taylor vs. Jack Catterall / 2020s
The official verdict produced an immediate judging scandal: Taylor was awarded a split decision by scores of 114–111 and 113–112, while one judge scored the bout 113–112 for Catterall. The result conflicted sharply with the statistical picture; CompuBox credited Catterall with landing more punches in 11 of the 12 rounds, while Taylor was also knocked down and appeared to be outworked. Former cruiserweight champion Johnny Nelson called the decision the kind that drives away casual fans and said Taylor had not won. The controversy became so severe that the British Boxing Board of Control opened an investigation into the scoring, while bookmaker Paddy Power announced refunds to customers who had bet on Catterall, describing the result as an 'absolute robbery.' Taylor rejected the demand for an immediate rematch and insisted he had won, deepening the feud rather than settling it. A rematch finally took place in Leeds on 18 May 2024, where Catterall won by unanimous decision; even then, Top Rank chief Bob Arum called the scorecards a disgrace and threatened to discourage his fighters from boxing in the United Kingdom. The episode remains a notorious example of how a disputed decision can damage a champion’s reputation, a governing body’s credibility, and a sport’s public trust without establishing that the scoring was deliberately corrupt.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.