Don Denkinger, Jorge Orta, St. Louis Cardinals vs. Kansas City Royals / 1980s
The Cardinals entered Game 6 leading the World Series three games to two and protecting a 1–0 lead in the bottom of the ninth inning. Kansas City's Jorge Orta opened the inning with a slow chopper toward first base. St. Louis first baseman Jack Clark fielded it and threw to pitcher Todd Worrell, who appeared to beat Orta to the bag. First-base umpire Don Denkinger nevertheless called Orta safe. Television replays, viewed from several angles, showed that Orta should have been ruled out, transforming what should have been one out and nobody on into a runner on first with no outs. The Cardinals briefly protested, but Denkinger refused to reverse his decision because he believed he had been correctly positioned. He later explained that Worrell's height, the high throw, the stadium noise, and his need to watch both the catch and Orta's foot made the play difficult to judge in real time.
The mistake became even more damaging when Clark lost a foul pop-up by Steve Balboni near the first-base dugout, after which Balboni singled. A sacrifice attempt, a passed ball by catcher Darrell Porter, and Herzog's decision to intentionally walk Hal McRae loaded the bases. Former Cardinal Dane Iorg then blooped a two-run single, giving the Royals a 2–1 walk-off victory and forcing a decisive Game 7. St. Louis manager Whitey Herzog later wrote that he considered asking Commissioner Peter Ueberroth to overrule the call and said he might have pulled his team from the field and forfeited had Ueberroth refused. Denkinger, who was scheduled to work home plate in Game 7, remained convinced he was right until seeing the replay with Ueberroth after the game. Kansas City then won Game 7, 11–0, completing one of baseball's most famous comeback victories and permanently attaching Denkinger's name to the series controversy.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.