Floyd Mayweather Jr. vs. José Luis Castillo / 2000s
On April 20, 2002, Floyd Mayweather Jr. moved up from super featherweight to challenge José Luis Castillo for the WBC and vacant The Ring lightweight titles in Las Vegas. Mayweather entered as a 5–1 favorite and dominated much of the opening five rounds with speed and defense, but Castillo changed the fight in the sixth by pressing forward and landing clean punches to Mayweather’s head and body. The bout became increasingly physical: Castillo lost a point in the eighth round for punching during a break, while Mayweather was penalized in the tenth for using his elbows. When the 12-round fight ended, the judges awarded Mayweather a wide decision, 115–111 twice and 116–111 once, despite official punch statistics showing Castillo landing more total punches, 203 to 157, and more power punches, 173 to 66. The decision immediately became one of the most disputed results of Mayweather’s career. HBO’s unofficial scorer Harold Lederman had Castillo winning 115–111, while Associated Press scored it for Mayweather by the same margin and USA Today columnist Dan Rafael saw the fight as a 114–114 draw. The controversy was intensified by Mayweather’s personal legal troubles: in the month before the bout, he accepted a plea bargain after being convicted on two domestic-violence counts and received a suspended sentence, avoiding prison and remaining eligible to fight. A Las Vegas Sun article questioned why Nevada still licensed him, while promoter Bob Arum insisted that the legal problems had not distracted him. The fight therefore entered boxing history not as a clean showcase of Mayweather’s superiority, but as a tangled episode involving a highly disputed scorecard, unusual statistical evidence, point deductions, and scrutiny of the champion’s conduct outside the ring.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.