The Appeals Board ultimately ruled that the greater weight of evidence showed the bell had sounded before Crapp's whistle. Doig's goal was erased from the official score, changing East Fremantle's total from 6.11 (47) to 5.11 (41) and converting the result into a one-point Perth victory, 6.6 (42) to 5.11 (41)—the first premiership in Perth's history. The decision provoked outrage in Fremantle newspapers; the Evening Mail branded it with the headline “Perth premiers: beaten in football, they win in argument,” while the Empire suggested that a largely Perth-based appeals board had shown regional and class bias against Fremantle clubs. East Fremantle captain Tom Wilson attacked the evidentiary process, arguing that Perth had been allowed to overwhelm the hearing with club-affiliated witnesses after East Fremantle had assumed such testimony would not be accepted. Perth captain Jack Leckie said his team would rather have won on the field and offered a rematch, but the league ruled that an official replay could not be arranged under the competition's procedural rules; East Fremantle declined an unofficial exhibition match and later threatened, unsuccessfully, to take the matter to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The controversy helped prompt the Australasian Football Council to amend the rules in November 1910, making the field umpire the sole judge of the first sound of the bell, effectively preventing similar protests from overturning results.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.