After the final, Go fans scrutinized the match for signs that the new rule had not been enforced consistently. Observers pointed to an incident in the opening game in which Byun's sleeve apparently moved another stone; he reset it without consulting the referee, and neither the official nor Ke Jie raised the matter during play. Fans also circulated footage suggesting that in the third game Byun pressed the Go clock before placing a captured stone on the bowl lid, potentially conflicting with the same procedural standard used against Ke Jie. These incidents were not established as formal violations, but they fueled accusations of selective enforcement because Ke Jie had received a two-point penalty, an automatic loss, and then another interruption under a rule introduced after the event had already begun. Critics argued that the retroactive application, vague timing requirements, and repeated intervention during Byun's thinking time transformed a world-class final into a dispute over officiating rather than a contest of skill. Chinese players including Ding Hao, Nie Weiping, Lian Xiao, and Tang Weixing condemned the handling of the match, while sponsor Ni Zhanggen called the referee the tournament's real protagonist and indicated that Byun could be barred from a future Menglily Cup. The Chinese Go Association subsequently announced a broad prohibition on foreign players in Chinese leagues for the season, a move expected to affect Korean professionals heavily.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.