The New Zealand Derby began in November 2024 as the A-League Men’s newest local rivalry, but Auckland FC immediately established a lopsided and psychologically damaging dominance over Wellington Phoenix. In the first meeting at Wellington’s Sky Stadium on 2 November 2024, Auckland won 2–0 before 26,252 spectators, with former Phoenix goalkeeper Alex Paulsen keeping a clean sheet and Jake Brimmer scoring twice in stoppage time. Auckland then mocked their rivals with a digital billboard outside the stadium reading, “Welcome to Ellington. We took the W back to Auckland.” The imbalance intensified as Auckland won the next derby 2–1, then demolished Wellington 6–1 in front of Auckland’s largest crowd to that point, with Logan Rogerson scoring the club’s first derby hat-trick and Phoenix teenager Luke Brooke-Smith becoming Wellington’s youngest scorer in the fixture.
The rivalry became even more dramatic during the 2025–26 season. In one match, Auckland survived after Dan Hall and Logan Rogerson were both sent off, leaving the club with nine players, while another saw Wellington defender Manjrekar James dismissed in the 46th minute. Auckland were awarded the first penalties in their history, but Wellington goalkeeper Josh Oluwayemi saved both attempts from Sam Cosgrove and Francis de Vries. The final match described in the source was even more humiliating for Wellington: Auckland won 5–0 away, including an own goal by Oluwayemi, a Jesse Randall brace, and further goals from Guillermo May and Lachlan Brook. After failing to beat Auckland in any of the six meetings, Wellington head coach Giancarlo Italiano resigned; across those matches, Auckland had outscored Phoenix 20–4.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.