Mike Andrews became the center of one of baseball's strangest World Series power struggles after two disastrous defensive plays in Game 2 of the 1973 World Series between the Oakland Athletics and New York Mets. In the bottom of the 12th inning, with Oakland trailing 7–6, John Milner's ground ball went through Andrews's legs, allowing Tug McGraw and Willie Mays to score. One batter later, Jerry Grote hit another grounder to Andrews; his throw pulled first baseman Gene Tenace off the bag, permitting Cleon Jones to score and giving New York a 10–7 victory. The two errors turned a tense extra-inning game into a Mets win, but the fallout became far more controversial than the fielding mistakes themselves.
Oakland owner Charlie Finley, notorious for his aggressive interference in baseball operations, attempted to remove Andrews from the rest of the Series by forcing him to sign a false affidavit claiming that he was injured. Finley's apparent goal was to make Andrews ineligible for Oakland's postseason roster, effectively converting two errors into an injury designation and avoiding the ordinary consequences of simply benching him. Manager Dick Williams and Andrews's teammates rallied behind the infielder, even taping Andrews's number 17 onto their uniforms in protest. Commissioner Bowie Kuhn intervened and ordered the Athletics to reinstate Andrews. He appeared in Game 4 as a pinch-hitter and received a standing ovation from sympathetic Mets fans, although he grounded out and Finley then kept him on the bench for the remainder of the Series. Oakland ultimately won its second consecutive World Series, but Andrews was given his unconditional release on November 1, 1973, and never appeared in another Major League game. He later played in Japan in 1975 before retiring. The episode became a landmark example of an owner attempting to manipulate a player's medical and roster status, prompting direct commissioner intervention and exposing the volatile relationship between Finley, Williams, and their players.
Follow the sources
Status and citations are supplied by the archive. AI concept art is an interpretation, not historical evidence.